1. Meaning and Definitions of Middle Class
The Most Difficult Social Class to Define Precisely
DefinitionThe middle class is the most difficult social class to define precisely — it is defined differently by different scholars, and its boundaries shift over time and across societies. At its core, it occupies the space between the owning/capitalist class and the manual working/labouring class.
| Source / Scholar | Definition | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| The Economist | If more than 1/3rd of income is left after paying for food and shelter, a household is middle class. | Economic/consumption-based definition. India crossed this threshold for millions post-2000. |
| B.B. Mishra | 75% to 125% of median salary defines middle class income band. | Statistical definition allowing comparison over time. Used in NCAER surveys. |
| General Sociological Definition | Either (a) owns means of production at lower scale than capitalist class, OR (b) sells skilled labour — unlike working class which sells unskilled labour. | Captures the dual character: old middle class (small owners) + new middle class (skilled professionals). |
| Karl Marx | Transitional and doomed class — petty bourgeoisie will be absorbed into proletariat as capitalism polarises. | Important: Marx was WRONG about India. Middle class expanded instead of declining. |
| Max Weber | Those with scarce skills in the market — doctors, lawyers, engineers, managers. Class = market situation determining life chances. | Weber more accurate for India — technical qualifications create a large, expanding middle class. |
Key pointMiddle class = between capitalist class and manual working class — defined by income, occupation, or market situation.
RememberE-M-S-M-W — Economist, Mishra, Sociological, Marx, Weber
Read the full notes (26 sections) in the EduSaint Odisha app
Free. All OPSC Sociology Paper I and Paper II notes, with mains PYQs.
Get the app on Google Play
Free. All OPSC Sociology Paper I and Paper II notes, with mains PYQs.
Get the app on Google Play
In these notes
- Meaning and Definitions of Middle Class
- Old vs New Middle Class — The Key Distinction
- Historical Evolution — Four Phases (D.L. Seth)
- Example: Phase I — Macaulay's Minute (1835) and the Clerisy
- Example: Phase III — Dalit Middle Class via Reservations
- Example: Phase IV — Infosys and the Techno-Professional Class
- Causes for the Rise of Middle Class in India
- B.B. Mishra — The Foundational Analysis
- D.L. Seth — Four-Phase Framework
- D.P. Mukherjee — Dialectical Synthesis
- Andre Beteille — Transitional and Contradictory
- Yogendra Singh — Rural vs. Urban Middle Class
- Sanjay Joshi — Heterogeneity and Modern Ways of Life
- Leela Fernandes — New Middle Class and Consumptionism
- Rajesh Kochar — Denationalised Middle Class
- Suhash Palshikar — Bourgeoisie Dependent on Middle Class
- Features and Characteristics of Indian Middle Class
- Contradictions and Ambiguities in Middle Class Values
- Gender, Family and Marriage Among Middle Classes
- Role of Middle Class — Positive Contributions
- Role of Middle Class — Critical and Negative Views
- The Great Indian Middle Class — Growth and Numbers (NCAER)
- Quick Revision — All Thinkers at a Glance
- Q: Discuss the emergence and role of the middle class in India's democracy and development.
- Overall Conclusion — Middle Class in India
- Exam Framework — Middle Class in India